(301) 304-3032
What Your Home Is Worth Before You List: Appraisal vs. Zestimate vs. Agent CMA

What Your Home Is Worth Before You List: Appraisal vs. Zestimate vs. Agent CMA

Before a house goes on the market, three numbers usually get discussed: the online estimate, the agent’s suggested price, and an appraisal. Sellers often treat them as three versions of the same thing. They are not. They are produced by different methods, for different purposes, and they carry different weight. What each one actually is The Zestimate is an automated valuation model. It compares public record data and recent sales using an algorithm. It does not enter the house, does not measure it, and cannot see condition, updates, or a bad floor plan. Zillow publishes a median error rate by market precisely because the number is an estimate, not a valuation. A comparative market analysis is prepared by a real estate agent. It lists active, pending, and recently sold properties and arrives at a suggested list price. It is a marketing and pricing tool, and a good agent’s CMA is genuinely useful for strategy. But it follows no professional appraisal standard, and it is written by someone whose income depends on getting the listing. An appraisal is prepared by a state-licensed appraiser working to USPAP. The appraiser inspects the interior, measures the dwelling, selects comparable sales, and documents an adjustment for every difference — square footage, condition, lot, garage, basement, updates. The result is a signed report with a defined effective date and a defensible value conclusion. Where the online estimate goes wrong In a market like Montgomery County, the failure modes are predictable: Public records lag. A renovation permitted in 2024 may still show as the 1998 configuration. Unpermitted work is invisible. The finished basement that never had...
The Real Estate Appraisal Group·11161 New Hampshire Ave, Ste 404, Silver Spring, MD 20904·(301) 304-3032·[email protected]